Brisbane Roar FC v Central Coast Mariners

Discussion in 'Central Coast Mariners FC' started by midfielder, Nov 26, 2019.


  1. true believer

    true believer Well-Known Member

    yeah i honestly think a back 3 and we lose 7 nil
    what we're doing isn't terrible from the standpoint of last season
    simon up front was a poor call and should be the last time he plays for the club he loves
    had staj started with milan instead of simon as a false 9 , we maybe win this
     
    • Like Like x 3
  2. turbo

    turbo Well-Known Member

    We haven’t got the players for a back 3 and that’s something you need to factor in when recruiting if you want to do it. Part of the idea seems to be to remove our dependence on Clisby but he’s the closest thing we have to a wingback. DDS isn’t, Silvera definitely isn’t.
     
    • Agree Agree x 1
  3. marinermick

    marinermick Well-Known Member

    Reality check this game. Replace Kennedy for Birraz and we would be dead last calling for big changes.
     
    • Agree Agree x 10
  4. Wombat

    Wombat Well-Known Member

    Leeds won 4.0 v Boro. Both sides played 3 at the back. Leeds had a very strange set up 3-3-3-1 with Bamford up top.
    Make of that what you will.
     
    • Interesting Interesting x 1
  5. Ads

    Ads Active Member


    With the wide backs so far up and not being able to receive the ball square and move forward are we not already playing with 3 backs when they have the ball?
     
    • Agree Agree x 1
  6. Capn Gus Bloodbeard

    Capn Gus Bloodbeard Well-Known Member

    So we don't play wingbacks then.

    Just looked at the goals....f**k me, what absolute trash. Clisby, doesn't even attempt the stop the ball going past his feet.
    Gordon, doesn't even attempt to stop O'Donovan. I mean, that's just pathetic, disgraceful defending. And we've seen that shit from Gordon way too often. Him and Clisby are just as lazy as each other. Utter trash.

    When I coached U/8 soccer, I used to run 'happy feet' drills with the team to encourage them to stay on their toes and not be flat footed. It seems that too many of these 'professionals' have forgotten the basics.

    And that 2nd goal - GG didn't even try to win that header.

    What the hell is going on in this team when we're conceding goals because our defenders can't even be bothered to try?

    2 weeks ago, watching a defence that was so bad they looked like they were playing under protest I started to wonder something that I'm still wondering - Has Staj lost the changing room?

    Because we're already seeing players who look like they just can't be stuffed being there. Watching the saves on Kayo, there was another run they had when Clisby didn't even attempt to win the header. I'm done with him. I'm surprised we didn't see more from Biri on that 2nd goal. He looked like he had started to move back that way.

    And questions need to be asked of Staj too. Tactically he's been found wanting a few times this season already. Starting Simon, and Silvera on the bench - what's that all about? We're at our most dangerous with DDS/Silvera on the park together.

    A month ago we were talking about being in the top 6. We had a defence that was pretty tight, we had a midfield that dominated and linked up to our attack, and players in attack that played well off each other and were approaching the box from all the angles and mixing it up.

    Now......what's gone wrong? Even if we take the City game out of the equation and put it down to just being controlled by the best team in the comp, that still leaves 3 games where we still looked like wooden spoon contenders (and I'm including the win....because WU should have beaten us 3-1, they just forgot how to finish). Now, sure, I don't know how the rest of this game went. but just from those highlights (and our shots didn't test their keeper...though Kim did test the crossbar), it looked like dross.

    Losing to a team like Brisbane - especially 2-0 - is just completely unacceptable.

    Biri is the only reason we're not stone motherless last. Perhaps Biri has been masking our problems - but he shouldn't be working that hard every game. Because unfortunately he does make mistakes too. The more he has to work, the more likely it is that his mistake will lead to a goal - and for most teams, the more you work the keeper, the more likely it is one will go through.
     
    • Agree Agree x 2
  7. Capn Gus Bloodbeard

    Capn Gus Bloodbeard Well-Known Member

    Haven't we still been saying that at this early stage of the season every year?
     
    • Agree Agree x 1
  8. Forum Phoenix

    Forum Phoenix Well-Known Member

    Disgraceful. Start playing Hatch. Clisby is a liability defensively AND can't attack. Hatch will help with the width and skill in attack we desperately need.
     
    • Like Like x 2
    • Agree Agree x 1
    • Winner Winner x 1
  9. turbo

    turbo Well-Known Member

    I also believe if you want to play that system you need at least one very dependable experienced CB, we don’t have one of those. You’re talking about wanting to drop Ziggy and Clisby, that leaves your options for that 3 as Tongyik, Fox, Rowles? You wouldn’t play Miller in that as he’s too green. GG could drop in there perhaps but we would miss him in midfield, you also picked him out too.

    I agree the question needs to be asked of Staj for that line up. At worst he got the tactical aspect very wrong, maybe there was a reason like niggling injuries we weren’t informed of but what he put out there according to the line up on the google match report that didn’t make much sense to me. I don’t have to even watch the game to say that and anyone that’s watched us would probably agree it’s not the set up they would have expected. Otherwise I don’t think Staj has been bad tactically. Let down by poor player performances at times though.

    That’s not really 3 at the back though and plenty of teams playing a back 4 have the wide backs getting advanced in possession. I wouldn’t say Sydney play a back 3 and both Grant and Zullo get forward a lot.
     
  10. Forum Phoenix

    Forum Phoenix Well-Known Member

    this for me
     
  11. Forum Phoenix

    Forum Phoenix Well-Known Member

    Agree. That's why it needs to be Hatch. Clisby is showing how he hard he worked with Kennedy to make us so awful.
     
    Last edited: Dec 2, 2019 at 6:02 AM
    • Agree Agree x 1
  12. Forum Phoenix

    Forum Phoenix Well-Known Member

    Easy to see why Staj started Simon. We had ZERO presence upfront last week and no territory. And Simon is the only player who you'd look at to be able to hold the ball up. To do it he had to drop Oar, DDS or Silvera. And he chose the youngest least experienced player. All makes perfect sense to me. But it didn't work because Simon is no longer of standard, Oar had his worse game of the season, Clisby and Miller can't link or get in behind and DDS still makes bad choices and cannot dictate play.

    We need a proper striker (2 to be honest). A better LB. Either DDS or Silvera central. And to fix our midfield balance. Stens GG and to Kim is not a good enough ball playing unit. They each do some good work, yet on balance they are being completely dominated every week. We need the better ball control of NIsbet and or Duric until we can strengthen our attack so that we can push teams back and defend less, like the last 15 against roar.

    Very disappointed we missed out on DWH. Many saw them as similar level as little as a few months ago. But his impact compared to Murray is chalk and cheese.

    FFC nailed it. There are positives, but we still have too much deadwood and we're simply being outclassed pound for pound at the moment.
     
    Last edited: Dec 2, 2019 at 6:12 AM
    • Agree Agree x 3
  13. Big Al

    Big Al Well-Known Member

    Ziggy Fox and Rowles could be a viable 3 as all defensive and Ziggy has experience as RB CB so would suit the right and Rowles the same for the left.

    However Roar have already pulled away from 3 at the back as wasn’t working for them. If they can’t do it I doubt we can.

    Also we haven’t been poor at the back.

    It’s the middle and attack the most that needs the work and changes.

    GG has at least 3 goals or penalties he’s responsible for. Ziggy got a little bit of bad luck on the first goal lady night and it changed the game.

    Apart from City and AU tearing holes we have been alot better at the back
     
    • Agree Agree x 2
  14. turbo

    turbo Well-Known Member

    Maybe if you’re going to do it you look at 3-4-3 with a diamond
    —————Birraz—————
    ——Ziggy—GG—Rowles——
    —————Kim————-
    ——Duric————Stensness
    —————DDS—————
    —Silvera ——Jair——Oar—

    That has a bit of flexibility built in. If you want GG in the mids you shuffle in Fox/Tongyik. They plus Miller are options if Ziggy is injured. Hatch or Clisby back up for Rowles (probably our weakest coverage). Duric or DDS can play the top of the diamond or Silvera too. Silvera can be covered by Murray or others if needed. Nisbet covers at any of the back 3 points of the diamond.
     
  15. turbo

    turbo Well-Known Member

    I was writing up a possible 3-4-3 as you responded but I agree with what you’re saying. I didn’t get to watch the game but you’re never taking 3 points without scoring. Even scoring the 1 makes it a tough ask to hold on to the points.

    We’ve scored 1 goal in 5 of our matches. 1 more against WSW gives us a draw. 1 more against Newcastle gives us a win. But we already knew about that issue.
     
    • Agree Agree x 2
    • Winner Winner x 1
  16. pjennings

    pjennings Well-Known Member

    I get the angst about Clisby - but cannot agree about Ziggy - especially at CB.He mad a mistake against O'Donovan, He got to the ball first and tried to clear it. He just didn't realise that Roy was coming round to block the clearance.

    Next game - we are coming off the bye and everyone should be fit - even Jair at least for 60 minutes.
     
    • Agree Agree x 4
    • Like Like x 2
  17. true believer

    true believer Well-Known Member

    clisby has to go . a kid can't be any worse
     
    • Agree Agree x 3
  18. shipwreck

    shipwreck Well-Known Member

    I'm amazed that Fox got frozen out after one bad game and Clisby hasn't.
     
    • Agree Agree x 4
    • Like Like x 1
    • Winner Winner x 1
  19. Ads

    Ads Active Member


    Sorry, my point is we are left with 3 to defend because the 4th full back is advanced when not appropriate.

    Grant and Zullo only advance when they have control of the ball and advance using triangles than a through ball to a cross or cut back.
     
    • Like Like x 1
    • Agree Agree x 1
  20. Tevor

    Tevor Well-Known Member

    We looked very flat, feel we might have on purpose started slow to deal with the warm humid weather. I feel Staj wasn’t happy with our energy levels as well hence his yellow, most animated i’ve seen him all season on the side line.

    Such a close comp with a win or loss you can move 4 places on the ladder.

    For me it was disappointing as I don’t rate Roar and to lose 2-0 is the poorest result so far this season. Seems like we lost intensity because the are not a top team. Second time we have played terrible after a win as well. Next three games will be difficult to even get a point out of which makes this loss a worst result for our position. Expect us to be last by 31 Dec.
     
    • Agree Agree x 3

Share This Page