All time favourite Mariner

[Gratis]

Does covering yourself in sky poo disqualify you from Mariners legend status?

I think it does.

Same if you go to the scum.

I don't blame several of our ex-players - Simon tried to stay and had no choice and Bernie had no choice at all - both remain candidates for highest Mariners honours.

As much as I genuinely hate to say this...
Wilko could have come back, was begged to in fact. He would have been worshipped. The money may have been a little less but rumour suggests maybe not that much less. He went to Bling-enemy-no-soul-fc by choice.
I hold nothing against him as he's a good guy who did a lot for us but for me he drops out of top mariner contention.

In that line of thinking I don't hold being at other clubs against many ex-mariners. Vukovic for example - all the best to him and he'd be welcome back.
Caceres and Austin can go f*#₹ themselves though

 

[midfielder]

In the LM era ... Danny V, Tommy P, Grumps and Jedi ...

In the Arnie days ... Dutchie, Ryan, Musty, Rogic, Pernz, Rogic, Bernie, Olly.

Post Arnie days... Monty, Fab...

If I had to pick a best IMO its a laydown to Jedi ... He left mid season and we never won another game that year.

To watch I would say the 10's ... Tommy P and Arnies 10's, Perez, Musty and Rogic and Olly as well.

Special mention to a couple of players Aloisi & Damian Mori.. both had short stints but both a joy to watch.

Again Jedi is my pick.. to watch in full flight Musty ...

 

[BrisRecky]

And in the Arnie Era....rogic, olly boz, Bernie , rose the elder, monty, Macca ( except for the era of the errant back heel pass, that shitted me off)....and on occasion Matty Simon

 

[true believer]

Gee rosey patty
Bernie
Now roy and posco
I have high hopes for liam rose

 

[Forum Phoenix]

Has to be Mile for me.

 

[sydmariner]

The goal machine our gf hero

 

[MagpieMariner]

Has to be Mile for me.

Jedinak or Sterj?

 

[Forum Phoenix]

 

[Wombat]

Jedinak or Sterj?

Sterj??????????????????????????????

Lovely bloke and played a couple of good games but come on Maggie??

 

[MagpieMariner]

I forgot to put the smiley after my question. Of course Jedi has the force. Sterj as you say is a lovely bloke and if we'd been privileged to watch him as a Mariner at the start of his career we might have a different view. I would have loved to see Sterj go around a couple more years, but just like Patrick, better to quit while you're on top.

 

[dibo]

He nearly scored the best goal in Mariners history in the 2013 grand final - that lob that kissed the crossbar...