Worst ever CCM XI (no current players)

[FFC Mariner]

Bored and as we end another year, what about a worst ever Mariners XI? Not appropriate to include any of the current squad IMHO and to be fair I dont think there are any contenders.

Sooooooo

Trotty in goals for starters

Back 4?

Tomasevic, O'Grady (?)

Others?

 

[Hagar the Horrible]

Would there be room for Leo Carle, Chris Tadrosse or Jamie McMaster?

 

[FFC Mariner]

I'll raise you a McAndrew and a Woodruffe

 

[Hagar the Horrible]

Does Dez Giraldi qualify?

 

[razza]

Trott
O'Grady McAndrew Tadrosse
Rizzo Carle McMaster Owens Tomasevic
Giraldi Woodruffe

 

[FFC Mariner]

Rizzo for being potentially so bad he wasnt trusted to get on the pitch?

 

[razza]

Forgout about the current player rule so chucked rizzo into my midfield. Backs were hard. Left back easy, but the rest hard

 

[pjennings]

Trott
O'Grady McAndrew Tadrosse
Rizzo Carle McMaster Owens Tomasevic
Giraldi Woodruffe

Stringers does not deserve to be in this company

 

[Tassiemariner]

Did that miranda? bloke ever properly sign on or was that only a trial?

 

[Atomic]

Trott
O'Grady McAndrew Tadrosse
Rizzo Carle McMaster Owens Tomasevic
Giraldi Woodruffe

Stringers does not deserve to be in this company

This thread is all about ranking each player in the position they play in against all of the other players that have played in that position. Just because a player is ranked lowest in that position, e.g. Stringers (arguably), doesn't mean he was a bad player, it just means we have been blessed with players of a higher quality than him at RB.

(There, that should soothe everyones anxiety).

Perhaps a complimentary thread would be the best CCM XI (current players included)

 

[Atomic]

Did that miranda? bloke ever properly sign on or was that only a trial?

How about Wrolly Wolfe (spelling) ???

 

[dru]

Doesn't Hutcho have to be named in every mariners squad

 

[Arabmariner]

Kwassie is a current player but also an ex-player so he should get in no problem.

 

[FFC Mariner]

I'd be tempted to put Sully in at RB. Worst crosser of a ball I can remember seeing.

Uncanny ability to hit the back of bay 16 from anywhere down the right hand side

 

[Arabmariner]

Petrie ?

Scored a few but there was plenty of pish in between.

 

[Wombat]

Petrie ?

Scored a few but there was plenty of pish in between.

Harsh.


Old man when we got him but clearly had a better Football brain than many of his team mates.

 

[FFC Mariner]

Petrie deserves some punishment for GF1

 

[Tassiemariner]

Won the V1 A-league golden boot though.

 

[pjennings]

Won the V1 A-league golden boot though.

And had a sweet left foot cross

 

[Wombat]

Trott wins hands down.

I'll have to think about worst 11