-
Join ccmfans.net
ccmfans.net is the Central Coast Mariners fan community, and was formed in 2004, so basically the beginning of time for the Mariners. Things have changed a lot over the years, but one thing has remained constant and that is our love of the Mariners. People come and go, some like to post a lot and others just like to read. It's up to you how you participate in the community!
If you want to get rid of this message, simply click on Join Now or head over to https://www.ccmfans.net/community/register/ to join the community! It only takes a few minutes, and joining will let you post your thoughts and opinions on all things Mariners, Football, and whatever else pops into your mind. If posting is not your thing, you can interact in other ways, including voting on polls, and unlock options only available to community members.
ccmfans.net is not only for Mariners fans either. Most of us are bonded by our support for the Mariners, but if you are a fan of another club (except the Scum, come on, we need some standards), feel free to join and get into some banter.
CCF possible split with FNSW
- Thread starter marinermick
- Start date
Who profits from the status quo? The role of the state federations needs to go under the microscope but they obviously wont support such an investigation and they've got the voting power with FA.
I was playing in the Hills division about 8 years ago when they split from FNSW. After one year FNSW came back cap in hand inviting them to rejoin. I moved to another area for reasons unrelated so I'm not sure what actually happened the following season and if they rejoined. Hills started their own referee assoc etc and nothing missed a beat for their first season away from FNSW.
It can be done and with little consequences for grass roots, where it has an impact is for the teams who want to participate in the state cups etc. Hills seen full teams move as a result, these were their Div 1 and Prem League teams. Otherwise they had so much money left over they provided kit bags and jumpers for every registered player. They also had a much better insurance deal than the one provided by FNSW.
It can be done and with little consequences for grass roots, where it has an impact is for the teams who want to participate in the state cups etc. Hills seen full teams move as a result, these were their Div 1 and Prem League teams. Otherwise they had so much money left over they provided kit bags and jumpers for every registered player. They also had a much better insurance deal than the one provided by FNSW.
marinermick
Well-Known Member
Dear Clubs and Participants,
As you may be aware, Central Coast Football (CCF) advised its members by way of an email newsletter dated 8 January 2022 that it has recently determined to pursue changes in its relationship with Football Australia and Football NSW.
Until recently, football on the Central Coast was officially governed by CCF. CCF was a member association of Football NSW, which is also a member of Football Australia. Football Australia is a member of the Asian Football Confederation and FIFA. This is the “football pyramid” and this is important as it is around this pyramid that the governance and administration of official football is built, both in Australia and around the world.
The communication from the CCF Board dated 8 January 2022 states that “Your clubs are aware of and fully support the board’s initiatives.” We are aware that concerns have been raised by CCF’s stakeholders which would suggest that such support is not universal within the region. It appears that the CCF Board has taken a decision with significant consequences in the absence of proper consultation with its members and the participants that they represent.
It is also clear that the CCF Board’s email newsletter did not accurately reflect the state of play, including the consequences arising from CCF’s decision to cease to be a member of the Australian football family.
It is against this backdrop that we write to inform you of the changes to how football is governed on the Central Coast.
These changes directly affect you and/or your children, so it is important that you are fully informed.
How did this happen?
Discussions have been taking place between representatives of Football Australia, Football NSW and CCF for well over a year and were initiated by CCF after announcing its intent to use a different registration system to the national platform used by all other community competitions, clubs and participants around the country, and to procure its own insurance program for 2021.
While Football Australia permitted CCF to use its own system in 2021 and was prepared to allow this to occur again in 2022, CCF advised it would again not participate in the Football NSW insurance program in 2022, nor pay the requisite governing body fees to Football Australia and Football NSW. It is apparent that CCF has decided to retain these fees for itself, rather than support the football ecosystem in Australia.
Despite efforts by Football Australia and Football NSW to find alternate solutions, CCF has chosen to take these unilateral steps, and therefore remove itself from this official pyramid – in other words, to disaffiliate from Australian football.
What does CCF’s decision mean for you?
You may rightly ask, “How does this impact me or my children, my club or my position as a coach or a referee?”
As a result of the CCF Board’s decision, the clubs, players and officials on the Central Coast will no longer be registered with Football Australia and will therefore not receive the benefits of being an official member of the Australian and global football community, including the following:
Participation in the national FFA Cup competition;
Participation in Football NSW’s State Cup and Champion of Champions competitions;
Ability to participate in the Domestic and International Transfer System, including the receipt of training compensation for CCF clubs;
Access to elite player, referee and coach pathways (including state representation);
Member Protection Framework and associated resources, including access to state and national Member Protection Information Officers (see https://www.footballaustralia.com.au/member-protection-framework);
Integrity framework and resources;
National Disciplinary and Grievance Procedures and arbitration tribunals;
National and state policies and procedures developed with access to best practice information;
Nationally accredited referees;
Inclusion of coaching CPD hours for the purposes of accreditation revalidation;
FIFA Club insurance compensation program;
Nationally funded football programs;
Federal and State Government funding programs, including Women’s World Cup 2023 Legacy Programs;
Club resources, such as those available under the National Club Development Program / any national club licensing program;
Association with a trusted brand through affiliation to the national sporting organisation;
Priority access to Socceroos and Commonwealth Bank Matildas tickets; and
Discounted tickets to Socceroos and Commonwealth Bank Matildas matches during a priority access window.
We note that the CCF Board’s purported reason for ceasing to be a member of the Australian football family is about a perceived lack of value provided by Football Australia and Football NSW. Put simply, CCF believes it can ‘deliver a better deal for its members’.
We reject this assertion, as it is impossible for CCF to deliver any of the official benefits listed above that only official football can provide.
The decision to abandon crucial national support mechanisms, such as member protection and child safeguarding, is especially concerning, and every parent whose child plays football on the Central Coast should also rightly be concerned at what this means.
We also have concerns that the benefits of having a centrally negotiated insurance program governed by Football NSW, which balances appropriate minimum coverage with affordability to participants, will be lost.
How do CCF’s actions impact the rest of Australian football?
The decision to disaffiliate means that Australian football has lost an important breeding ground for exciting young talent, whether as a player, coach, referee or administrator.
It also destabilises the rest of the game and undermines the role of Football Australia not just in grassroots football but in many other aspects of the game.
For example, Football Australia would in normal circumstances have collected $14 for each child and $33 for each adult playing football on the Central Coast. These fees support Football Australia to deliver all the services list above, help to administer our youth national team program, advocate on behalf of our game to Government (including bringing the FIFA Women’s World Cup to Australia in 2023) and stage Commonwealth Bank Matildas and Socceroos matches.
By unilaterally deciding to withhold these funds, CCF has limited Football Australia’s ability to do the important things that inspire so many Australians to love and to follow the game.
Your fees
One of many questions participants may wish to direct to CCF is what it intends to do with the season 2021 fees it has collected based on being affiliated to Football NSW and Football Australia. In other words, what will CCF do with fees collected from participants that are payable to Football NSW and Football Australia?
For the 2021 season, CCF indicated that it was willing to collect the governing body fees from registered participants but now appears unwilling to pass the full amount of those fees to Football NSW and Football Australia as required for the services we provide, despite CCF’s representations to its participants that their registration fees included a component payable to Football NSW and Football Australia.
A further question participants may wish to ask CCF is whether it will be charging them an equivalent amount of the Football NSW and Football Australia governing body fees for 2022 and if so what will it do with those fees which no longer need to be passed on?
Given the timing of CCF’s decision so close to the 2022 season, we are aware that representations have again been made to participants about the use of the fees charged to play football. It is important therefore for you to understand that, given the CCF board’s position, no part of your season 2022 registration fees will be provided by CCF to Football NSW and Football Australia. We wish to be clear that that participants on the Central Coast are not currently supporting association football in Australia, including the Australian National Teams.
The use of such income by Football Australia and Football NSW is disclosed fully in each organisation’s audited financial statements and annual review – both of which are accessible to the public online (see www.footballaustralia.com.au and www.footballnsw.com.au).
What happens next, and who can you talk to?
Football Australia and Football NSW are determined to ensure that participants on the Central Coast can re-join the Australian football family as soon as possible.
We continue to update FIFA on the situation and have also commenced discussions with the NSW Government, and local Government to ensure they understand the decision the board of CCF has taken, and what it means, including some serious implications for the participants and clubs in the region.
We encourage all participants on the Central Coast to engage with Football Australia and Football NSW about this development. To contact us directly, please send an email to centralcoast@footballaustralia.com.au. Furthermore, we intend to arrange various forums in due course for participants to engage in a broader discussion and to explore solutions and possible alternatives.
Yours sincerely
James Johnson
Chief Executive Officer and General Secretary
As you may be aware, Central Coast Football (CCF) advised its members by way of an email newsletter dated 8 January 2022 that it has recently determined to pursue changes in its relationship with Football Australia and Football NSW.
Until recently, football on the Central Coast was officially governed by CCF. CCF was a member association of Football NSW, which is also a member of Football Australia. Football Australia is a member of the Asian Football Confederation and FIFA. This is the “football pyramid” and this is important as it is around this pyramid that the governance and administration of official football is built, both in Australia and around the world.
The communication from the CCF Board dated 8 January 2022 states that “Your clubs are aware of and fully support the board’s initiatives.” We are aware that concerns have been raised by CCF’s stakeholders which would suggest that such support is not universal within the region. It appears that the CCF Board has taken a decision with significant consequences in the absence of proper consultation with its members and the participants that they represent.
It is also clear that the CCF Board’s email newsletter did not accurately reflect the state of play, including the consequences arising from CCF’s decision to cease to be a member of the Australian football family.
It is against this backdrop that we write to inform you of the changes to how football is governed on the Central Coast.
These changes directly affect you and/or your children, so it is important that you are fully informed.
How did this happen?
Discussions have been taking place between representatives of Football Australia, Football NSW and CCF for well over a year and were initiated by CCF after announcing its intent to use a different registration system to the national platform used by all other community competitions, clubs and participants around the country, and to procure its own insurance program for 2021.
While Football Australia permitted CCF to use its own system in 2021 and was prepared to allow this to occur again in 2022, CCF advised it would again not participate in the Football NSW insurance program in 2022, nor pay the requisite governing body fees to Football Australia and Football NSW. It is apparent that CCF has decided to retain these fees for itself, rather than support the football ecosystem in Australia.
Despite efforts by Football Australia and Football NSW to find alternate solutions, CCF has chosen to take these unilateral steps, and therefore remove itself from this official pyramid – in other words, to disaffiliate from Australian football.
What does CCF’s decision mean for you?
You may rightly ask, “How does this impact me or my children, my club or my position as a coach or a referee?”
As a result of the CCF Board’s decision, the clubs, players and officials on the Central Coast will no longer be registered with Football Australia and will therefore not receive the benefits of being an official member of the Australian and global football community, including the following:
Participation in the national FFA Cup competition;
Participation in Football NSW’s State Cup and Champion of Champions competitions;
Ability to participate in the Domestic and International Transfer System, including the receipt of training compensation for CCF clubs;
Access to elite player, referee and coach pathways (including state representation);
Member Protection Framework and associated resources, including access to state and national Member Protection Information Officers (see https://www.footballaustralia.com.au/member-protection-framework);
Integrity framework and resources;
National Disciplinary and Grievance Procedures and arbitration tribunals;
National and state policies and procedures developed with access to best practice information;
Nationally accredited referees;
Inclusion of coaching CPD hours for the purposes of accreditation revalidation;
FIFA Club insurance compensation program;
Nationally funded football programs;
Federal and State Government funding programs, including Women’s World Cup 2023 Legacy Programs;
Club resources, such as those available under the National Club Development Program / any national club licensing program;
Association with a trusted brand through affiliation to the national sporting organisation;
Priority access to Socceroos and Commonwealth Bank Matildas tickets; and
Discounted tickets to Socceroos and Commonwealth Bank Matildas matches during a priority access window.
We note that the CCF Board’s purported reason for ceasing to be a member of the Australian football family is about a perceived lack of value provided by Football Australia and Football NSW. Put simply, CCF believes it can ‘deliver a better deal for its members’.
We reject this assertion, as it is impossible for CCF to deliver any of the official benefits listed above that only official football can provide.
The decision to abandon crucial national support mechanisms, such as member protection and child safeguarding, is especially concerning, and every parent whose child plays football on the Central Coast should also rightly be concerned at what this means.
We also have concerns that the benefits of having a centrally negotiated insurance program governed by Football NSW, which balances appropriate minimum coverage with affordability to participants, will be lost.
How do CCF’s actions impact the rest of Australian football?
The decision to disaffiliate means that Australian football has lost an important breeding ground for exciting young talent, whether as a player, coach, referee or administrator.
It also destabilises the rest of the game and undermines the role of Football Australia not just in grassroots football but in many other aspects of the game.
For example, Football Australia would in normal circumstances have collected $14 for each child and $33 for each adult playing football on the Central Coast. These fees support Football Australia to deliver all the services list above, help to administer our youth national team program, advocate on behalf of our game to Government (including bringing the FIFA Women’s World Cup to Australia in 2023) and stage Commonwealth Bank Matildas and Socceroos matches.
By unilaterally deciding to withhold these funds, CCF has limited Football Australia’s ability to do the important things that inspire so many Australians to love and to follow the game.
Your fees
One of many questions participants may wish to direct to CCF is what it intends to do with the season 2021 fees it has collected based on being affiliated to Football NSW and Football Australia. In other words, what will CCF do with fees collected from participants that are payable to Football NSW and Football Australia?
For the 2021 season, CCF indicated that it was willing to collect the governing body fees from registered participants but now appears unwilling to pass the full amount of those fees to Football NSW and Football Australia as required for the services we provide, despite CCF’s representations to its participants that their registration fees included a component payable to Football NSW and Football Australia.
A further question participants may wish to ask CCF is whether it will be charging them an equivalent amount of the Football NSW and Football Australia governing body fees for 2022 and if so what will it do with those fees which no longer need to be passed on?
Given the timing of CCF’s decision so close to the 2022 season, we are aware that representations have again been made to participants about the use of the fees charged to play football. It is important therefore for you to understand that, given the CCF board’s position, no part of your season 2022 registration fees will be provided by CCF to Football NSW and Football Australia. We wish to be clear that that participants on the Central Coast are not currently supporting association football in Australia, including the Australian National Teams.
The use of such income by Football Australia and Football NSW is disclosed fully in each organisation’s audited financial statements and annual review – both of which are accessible to the public online (see www.footballaustralia.com.au and www.footballnsw.com.au).
What happens next, and who can you talk to?
Football Australia and Football NSW are determined to ensure that participants on the Central Coast can re-join the Australian football family as soon as possible.
We continue to update FIFA on the situation and have also commenced discussions with the NSW Government, and local Government to ensure they understand the decision the board of CCF has taken, and what it means, including some serious implications for the participants and clubs in the region.
We encourage all participants on the Central Coast to engage with Football Australia and Football NSW about this development. To contact us directly, please send an email to centralcoast@footballaustralia.com.au. Furthermore, we intend to arrange various forums in due course for participants to engage in a broader discussion and to explore solutions and possible alternatives.
Yours sincerely
James Johnson
Chief Executive Officer and General Secretary
And that's where he lost me. If he's not willing to acknowledge how useless that insurance is and start detailing what we get back from Football NSW for their substantial cut of fees then he's not showing me he's looking out for football on the coast.
marinermick
Well-Known Member
I have done some more reading on this and both insurances are junk. Last season under the CCF insurance a mate of mine only received $200 back from an $8000 operation. From what I understand the government is regulating these junk insurances and the FA are currently in negotiation with Zurich for a cheaper scheme that will blow anything out of the water in terms of coverage.
Besides are we really squabbling over an insurance bills that equates to around $20 per head and don’t address the fact that big clubs like Killarney and Terrigal charge $460 for a senior player while I pay $350 at Ourimbah and others pay $290 at Tuggerah?
The CCF Board has some mixed up notion about value. Maybe if they weren’t paid to be on the board, in a not-for-profit, their thinking might be a bit clearer.
It’s not just about the insurance, the football NSW component is substantial (I feel like it’s $80ish for seniors) and it’s very opaque what we get back for it. That part isn’t optional and unlike individual clubs gouging I can’t just decide to play elsewhere to avoid paying the NSW part. I’m ok with the amount that goes to my club (Gosford)
marinermick
Well-Known Member
You are incorrect. Minus the insurance the FNSW component is $14 per head and the FA component averages out to $25 per head. As I said around ten percent of a total senior rego.
Some of you would be paying more than that per head to pay for your first grade coach and the BPL program.
And if you don’t believe my figures the financials are laid out in the report page of the CCF website that includes an $80000 fee paid to the CEO’s associates and family. It is all clear and easy to work out what we pay per head.
Looking at a screenshot I took from the rego process in 2019 the break down was:
FFA 33
Football NSW 83
FNSW - CCF 126
My club 147
I don’t recall it getting any cheaper since. If that shitty insurance is worth $50-60 per head then someone is having a laugh.
marinermick
Well-Known Member
Look at CCF financials. $480000 odd went to affiliation fees and $270000 to insurance. Do the maths on 14800 registered players that is listed on the CCF website.
Those figures are from the registration process via playfootball when it was used. Why would I have reason to believe they aren’t accurate.
marinermick
Well-Known Member
You quoted 2019 figures
marinermick
Well-Known Member
I know someone who got $200 back from a $8k knee operation last season under the CCF insurance
midfielder
Well-Known Member
Has massive implications for Australian Football....
Huddo
Well-Known Member
I can see both sides of this argument, the issue is value for money, CCF don't think they're getting it, FNSW think they're giving it.
Simple solution, open the books, bring in independent auditors. Lay out the positives and negatives to going it alone, and staying with FNSW, because right now all I am seeing is 2 narratives by 2 vested interest's.
Simple solution, open the books, bring in independent auditors. Lay out the positives and negatives to going it alone, and staying with FNSW, because right now all I am seeing is 2 narratives by 2 vested interest's.
marinermick
Well-Known Member
Books are open and financials are known. At last night’s CCF competition’s meeting the figure of $250000 was bandied about as the savings from the move. This equates to around $17 per registered player.
Given that most senior club regos are $340 plus (some are $460( this only represents under five percent of the total registration fee.
If the average player thinks they will get cheaper football out of this they will be sorely disappointed.
Conversely some clubs are paying up to $30000 to their senior coach and their premier league program in the $50000 range. For these clubs that is around $50 per registered player in that club.
Therefore if you are going to have a discussion about value at board level it needs to be a more holistic one rather than isolate an easy target and blame all the woes on that target.
Huddo
Well-Known Member
A holistic approach is what I'm saying.
Prices may be high, but why? what do we get from each of the areas to which we contribute? Is it value for money? Can it be done more cost effectively? Can costs be capped in certain areas?
And yes, the CCF needs to be just as accountable as FNSW and the FA in the review.
Wombat
Well-Known Member
I got $200 after 6 weeks on crutches....the insurance is a joke. Lucky my brain doesn't work and after 1 day off i continued to work.....imagine trying to survive if you have literally severed your foot!!
Online statistics
- Members online
- 24
- Guests online
- 295
- Total visitors
- 319
